Which Chocolate Ice Cream Is the Best? Top Picks for Every Preference

Sabrina Dawson

which chocolate ice cream is the best
Rate this post

Chocolate ice cream is more than just a treat; it’s an experience. It can transform a bad day, lift spirits, and bring people together. The quest for the best chocolate ice cream is both delicious and daunting, given the myriad of options available. In this blog post, we will dive deep into various categories of chocolate ice cream, examining the best choices for every preference and dietary need.

The Magic of Chocolate Ice Cream

Chocolate ice cream has a unique power. Place a container of Neapolitan ice cream in a break room, and watch the chocolate disappear first. It’s a universal favorite, but what makes one chocolate ice cream better than another? The best chocolate ice cream should be creamy, have a deep cocoa flavor, and be so irresistible that you can’t help but have another scoop.

Categories of Chocolate Ice Cream

To find the best chocolate ice cream, we’ve divided them into several categories:

  • Best Keto
  • Best with Cake
  • Best Budget
  • Best Dairy-Free
  • Best White Chocolate
  • Best Cheap Dark Chocolate
  • Best Over-the-Top
  • Best Texture
  • Best Dark Chocolate
  • Best Chocolate Chip
  • Best of the Best

Let’s dive into each category to find the standout options.

Best Keto Chocolate Ice Cream

Enlightened Triple Chocolate Brownie Dough

We Taste-Tested 10 Different Enlightened Keto Ice Cream Pints | Hip2Keto

If you’re following a keto diet, finding a satisfying ice cream can be a challenge. Many keto ice creams are hard and lack the creamy texture we crave. Enlightened Triple Chocolate Brownie Dough breaks this mold. It’s soft, airy, and incredibly decadent. Sporked contributor Danny Palumbo described it as “decadent, fatty, and rich,” comparing it to a Fudgesicle. It’s the top choice for keto chocolate ice cream lovers who are watching their carbs but still want a rich chocolate experience.

Best Chocolate Ice Cream to Eat with Cake

Turkey Hill Belgian Chocolate

Ice cream review: Turkey Hill's Belgian Style Chocolate - masslive.com

Belgian chocolate is renowned for its dark, bitter profile, but Turkey Hill’s Belgian Chocolate ice cream brings a pleasant nutty flavor with a mild Belgian bite. It might not be the most exciting option on its own, but it shines when paired with other desserts, particularly cake. Sporked editor-in-chief Justine Sterling noted that it’s “maybe-not-quite-enough-on-its-own-but-good-with-something” ice cream. It’s the perfect complement to a slice of cake, enhancing the dessert experience without overpowering it.

Best Budget Chocolate Ice Cream

Great Value Chocolate Ice Cream

Great Value Chocolate Ice Cream, 48 fl oz - Walmart.com

For those who want a tasty, affordable chocolate ice cream, Great Value Chocolate Ice Cream from Walmart is a standout. Described as the “Yoo-hoo of ice cream,” it delivers a basic but delicious chocolate flavor. Danny likened it to the milk left behind after eating a bowl of Cocoa Pebbles. It’s sold by the gallon for less than six bucks, making it the best choice for serving a crowd without breaking the bank.

Best Dairy-Free Chocolate Ice Cream

Cado Deep Dark Chocolate Non-Dairy Avocado Frozen Dessert

Say Goodbye to Avo Toast and Hello to Cado Ice Cream - Brit + Co

Vegan and non-dairy ice creams often struggle to match the creaminess and flavor of their dairy counterparts. However, Cado Deep Dark Chocolate Non-Dairy Avocado Frozen Dessert stands out. It’s smooth, creamy, and rich, with a deep chocolate flavor that doesn’t have the typical aftertaste found in many vegan ice creams. According to Jordan from Sporked, it tastes like it’s made with full-fat dairy, making it a top pick for those who can’t or choose not to consume dairy.

Best White Chocolate Ice Cream

Tillamook Udderly Chocolate Ice Cream

Tillamook Ice Cream: Old-Fashioned Vanilla, Vanilla Bean & Udderly Chocolate Review

White chocolate is a tricky flavor to perfect. It’s not quite vanilla and not quite traditional chocolate, but when done right, it’s a delightful experience. Tillamook Udderly Chocolate Ice Cream combines white and milk chocolate, creating a creamy, fluffy texture reminiscent of soft serve. It even includes chocolatey bits, making it a hit for both white and milk chocolate lovers. It’s a perfect blend for those who enjoy the delicate flavor of white chocolate but still crave a hint of traditional chocolate.

Best Cheap Dark Chocolate Ice Cream

Private Selection Chocolate Ganache

Chocolate Ganache & Vanilla Bean - Private Selection

Elegance and affordability don’t often go hand in hand, but Private Selection Chocolate Ganache ice cream manages both. Described as “a velvet gown slipping over my tongue” by Sporked’s Jordan, it offers a nice, dark, and deep chocolate flavor with a dreamy, silky texture. It’s an excellent budget-friendly choice for those who want a sophisticated dark chocolate ice cream without the high price tag.

Best Over-the-Top Chocolate Ice Cream

Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Therapy

Ben and Jerry's Chocolate Therapy Ice Cream Review – Ice Cream Recovery Reviews and Ratings

When it comes to indulgence, Ben & Jerry’s never disappoints. Their Chocolate Therapy ice cream is a chocolate lover’s dream, combining traditional chocolate ice cream with chocolate pudding ice cream swirls. While some might find it a bit lacking in chocolate cookie bits, the overall flavor and richness make it a winner. It’s perfect for those days when you want to treat yourself to an over-the-top chocolate experience.

Best Texture in Chocolate Ice Cream

Haagen-Dazs Double Belgian Chocolate Chip

David's Ice Cream Reviews: Häagen-Dazs - Belgian Chocolate

Haagen-Dazs is known for its high-quality ingredients and impeccable texture. The Double Belgian Chocolate Chip flavor takes their already excellent chocolate ice cream and adds the fun of chocolate flecks. The experience is akin to eating ice cream covered in a chocolate shell, providing a delightful textural contrast. It’s smooth, rich, and utterly satisfying, making it the top choice for those who value texture in their ice cream.

Best Dark Chocolate Ice Cream

Jeni’s Darkest Chocolate

Jeni's Darkest Chocolate Ice Cream, 43% OFF

Jeni’s Darkest Chocolate ice cream is perfect for true dark chocolate aficionados. Its warm, rich flavor is ideal for cooler weather, and the creamy mouthfeel enhances the overall experience. The flavor evolves as you eat it, making each bite a new adventure. It’s the best choice for those who prefer a more intense chocolate experience without the sweetness of milk chocolate.

Best Chocolate Chip Ice Cream

Alden’s Organic Chocolate Chocolate Chip

Alden's Ice Cream Chocolate Chocolate Chip, 41% OFF

Alden’s Organic Chocolate Chocolate Chip ice cream combines excellent chocolate flavor with delicate chocolate chips. The chips are more like shards or flecks, adding a subtle crunch without overwhelming the smoothness of the ice cream. While it takes a bit longer to soften for scooping, the wait is worth it for the texture and flavor it delivers.

Best of the Best

Straus Organic Dutch Chocolate

Organic Dutch Chocolate Ice Cream | 1 quart | Straus Family Creamery | Good Eggs

After extensive taste tests, Straus Organic Dutch Chocolate emerged as the best chocolate ice cream overall. Its smooth, fluffy texture and deep, rich flavor evoke a sense of nostalgia, reminiscent of childhood memories. Sporked’s Justine described it as sparking a Proustian sense memory, likening it to a cherished ice cream cone at a county fair. It’s a top-tier choice that stands out in both taste and texture, making it the ultimate chocolate ice cream experience.


The search for the best chocolate ice cream can lead to a delightful journey through various flavors and textures. Whether you’re looking for a keto-friendly option, a budget choice, or the most indulgent chocolate experience, there’s an ice cream on this list for you. Each category winner brings something unique to the table, catering to different tastes and dietary needs. So grab a spoon, dig in, and enjoy the wonderful world of chocolate ice cream.